Navigating the Friction Economy: How Enterprise Leaders Balance Advanced Fraud Prevention with Customer Experience

Online fraud has evolved from isolated, opportunistic attacks into a sophisticated, industrialized enterprise. For modern businesses, stopping illicit actors is no longer just a technical hurdle; it is a delicate balancing act that directly impacts revenue, operational costs, and long-term customer loyalty. According to the Merchant Risk Council’s 2026 Global Ecommerce Payments and Fraud Report—which surveyed more than 1,200 merchants across 37 countries—98% of businesses reported experiencing at least one fraud attack over the past year. Furthermore, the share of accepted orders that ultimately proved fraudulent rose from 3.0% to 3.5%, while refund and policy abuse emerged as the single most common vector of attack.
Compounding these challenges, merchants are seeing an increase in false positives—instances where legitimate customers are incorrectly flagged and turned away as suspected fraud. This phenomenon underscores the central dilemma facing modern commerce: every defensive measure introduces the risk of added friction, delayed refunds, or lost sales.
The Macro Landscape: Rising Fraud and Shifting Attack Vectors
The financial services sector faces a parallel onslaught. Data from the Association for Financial Professionals’ 2026 Payments Fraud and Control Survey reveals that 76% of U.S. organizations experienced attempted or actual payments fraud in the previous year. While check fraud remains historically prevalent, ACH debits and wire transfers have become primary targets for digital criminals.
As fraud methods grow more automated, perpetrators are shifting their focus away from vulnerable transactions and toward identities and behavioral patterns. This evolution was a central theme in a recent webinar series produced in partnership with Riskified and examined by industry leaders, including Jeff Otto, Chief Marketing Officer at Riskified; Danielle Dzbanek, Senior Director of Analytics at Riskified; Robert Rose, Senior Director of Customer Experience at Adobe; and Debjit Saha, VP of Engineering and Product, Risk and Compliance at MoneyGram.
Across ecommerce, software, and international remittances, these experts emphasize that modernizing fraud prevention without stymying business growth requires a fundamental shift in strategy. Rather than applying blunt rules across all buyers, organizations must adopt precision-led techniques: resolving identities across networks, monitoring behavioral anomalies within trusted accounts, matching friction dynamically to risk, and establishing a unified policy backbone across risk and customer experience (CX) teams.
Resolving Identities Across the Network to Isolate Bad Actors
To understand the scale of modern fraud, enterprise risk teams must look beyond individual data silos. Jeff Otto of Riskified notes that identities associated with direct fraud losses typically represent a mere 20 basis points of a merchant’s customer base—a proportion he compares to "a few drops of poison in a lake."
However, these bad actors rarely appear small within transactional systems. A single individual or organized ring may operate dozens or even hundreds of interconnected accounts. Consequently, the primary challenge for risk leaders is not determining whether a single transaction looks suspicious, but whether seemingly disparate accounts ultimately belong to the same orchestrator.
Danielle Dzbanek explains that professional fraud rings systematically exploit blind spots across multiple merchants. Historically, attackers studied a single site, identified its vulnerabilities, and concentrated their efforts there. Today, fraudsters are platform-agnostic; they care primarily about acquiring high-value goods, seamlessly transferring successful attack vectors from one retailer to another. Because individual merchants view only their own slice of the transaction stream, no single business can recognize the broader pattern in isolation.
To illustrate this, Dzbanek points to an account-takeover ring tracked by Riskified within the ticketing sector. The operation began with small, low-risk test purchases, escalated once successful, and systematically replicated the exact same pattern across six different merchants over a span of several months.
"If you’re sitting in your silo, it’s hard to know what’s going on out there," Dzbanek emphasizes. "You need that network effect now. You can’t work in isolation anymore. You can’t look at your own population and try to stop fraud there."
A striking real-world example of this phenomenon involved Amazon-owned home security provider Ring. According to Otto, the company suffered roughly $4 million in losses stemming from refund abuse—losses that were ultimately traced back to just 600 individuals who had generated tens of thousands of fraudulent accounts to execute "refund-as-a-service" schemes.
Overcoming these coordinated networks requires advanced identity resolution: systematically linking physical addresses, email accounts, phone numbers, IP addresses, digital devices, and payment credentials. When executed effectively, a data platform that initially registers 50 distinct buyers can resolve them into a single operator running a coordinated fraud ring. Once isolated, enterprises can apply stringent controls specifically to those malicious actors without imposing burdensome verification steps on legitimate shoppers.
Furthermore, network-level intelligence alters how organizations should evaluate first-time customers. Even if a shopper has never interacted with a specific brand, their underlying shipping addresses, devices, and purchasing patterns often exist elsewhere in the broader ecosystem, transforming an ostensibly "unknown" customer into a recognized entity.
Behavioral Intelligence: Catching Threats Inside Trusted Accounts
As enterprises have fortified their defenses around new account creation, fraudsters have adapted by shifting their focus toward aged, established accounts. Dark web and clear web monitoring by Riskified analysts over the past year revealed a marked increase in the market value of compromised, mature accounts.
Debjit Saha of MoneyGram highlights this strategic pivot by fraudsters: "Over the years, there has been a lot of focus on new customers, having rules and patterns on new customers. But there has been this concept: we know that this particular customer behaves in a certain way. There’s an established account, and that’s why the aged accounts have so much more value to the fraudsters, because they know that’s much weaker in terms of where the controls are today."
To catch threats operating within trusted accounts, organizations must move beyond static identity checks. As Otto observes, knowing your neighbor does not mean it is normal to find them sitting in your kitchen at midnight. While identity resolution establishes who a user is, behavioral intelligence asks whether what that identity is doing at any given moment makes logical sense.
Dzbanek shares an instructive case of device takeover where traditional identity signals remained completely legitimate. The fraudster was operating from the victim’s actual smartphone, meaning the IP address, home location, and saved mobile wallet credentials matched baseline expectations. The attack was ultimately uncovered through subtler anomalies: customers previously associated with newer operating systems (such as Android 14) suddenly appearing on outdated versions (such as Android 10) with fewer native security controls; buyers navigating through unusually few pages at rapid speeds during late-night hours; and identical behavioral combinations appearing simultaneously across multiple customer profiles.
Over a three-month monitoring period, this particular scheme generated more than $1 million in attempted fraud across five distinct ticketing platforms within Riskified’s network. While any single transaction appeared normal on its surface, the aggregated behavioral pattern revealed the underlying fraud ring.
Adaptive Friction: Protecting Revenue and the Customer Journey
In the high-stakes environment of digital commerce and global remittances, maximizing security at the expense of user experience can be catastrophic. Debjit Saha points out a fundamental industry truth: "We can have zero fraud if we do zero transactions."
Because customer experience serves as a core competitive differentiator, piling on static verification steps often causes severe customer drop-off. To combat this, money-movement and ecommerce leaders are increasingly turning to "adaptive friction." Under this model, customers who exhibit clean trust signals glide through the purchase funnel with minimal interruption, while systemic scrutiny scales upward dynamically only as risk indicators accumulate.
Otto warns that demanding a zero-fraud mandate can inadvertently destroy millions of dollars in revenue as frustrated, over-protected customers abandon checkout funnels entirely. Leading organizations measure approval rates meticulously across multiple segments—distinguishing between new and existing customers, as well as payment methods like cards and ACH.
Beyond immediate transaction declines, businesses must also account for the lifetime value lost following an account takeover and the long-term brand erosion associated with excessive friction. By calibrating a digital "trust dial," enterprises can adjust their responses granularly. For instance, while a high-risk identity may face stricter checkout conditions, a high-value customer who accidentally triggers a risk control can be routed to a concierge support line rather than facing an automated decline. Merchants implementing these nuanced strategies have observed significant improvements in repurchase rates alongside reductions in customer complaints.
Unifying Policy Across Risk and Customer Experience
A persistent operational challenge for large enterprises is the organizational divide between risk-prevention teams and customer experience departments. Robert Rose of Adobe notes that policy abuse—such as repeat refund requests, serial cancellations, or promotional manipulation—often falls into a gray area between traditional fraud and general customer dissatisfaction.
"This often creates backlogs. It creates inconsistent resolutions. It creates tension between the customer experience teams that are chasing that satisfaction goal and the risk teams that are looking to prevent loss," Rose explains. "What we’ve found is that when our policies aren’t clear and they aren’t equally managed across all of those channels, our trust and our reputation often suffer."
In large corporate environments, bridging this gap requires moving beyond informal coordination to embed shared policies directly into enterprise software and data architecture. Automated chatbots, frontline support agents, and backend risk engines must operate from a single, unified policy backbone. When automated systems and human agents are aligned under common standards, businesses eliminate the inconsistencies that bad actors routinely exploit.
The Financial and Strategic Return on Investment
Implementing an integrated, data-driven approach to fraud intelligence yields profound financial benefits. Industry implementations have demonstrated that major department stores and global platforms can secure millions of dollars in direct annual savings while simultaneously recovering substantial revenue previously lost to unnecessary transaction declines.
Ultimately, the modernization of fraud prevention represents an evolution from defensive restriction to strategic enablement. By deploying advanced identity resolution, real-time behavioral monitoring, adaptive friction, and cross-functional policy alignment, enterprise leaders can successfully neutralize sophisticated fraud networks while delivering frictionless experiences for genuine customers.







